What’s the Deal With Over-Balancing?
Increasing the reciprocating mass above the commonly accepted 50 percent (of measured) rotating mass can be helpful in extreme high-rpm applications—emphasis on the word “can.”
Jon Greenbaum; New Haven, CT: I just bought a 347-cube stroker kit for my 302 Ford. The kit includes a crank, pistons, rods, pins, rings, and bearings. The package came with a balance sheet indicating it has been pre-balanced, and I don’t have to spend the money again for balancing. But my machine shop tells me otherwise. Who is right, the crank company or my machinist? Also, we got talking about over- and under-balancing. It was confusing. What’s the deal?
Steve Magnante: Most of today’s prepackaged stroker kits arrive in a pre-balanced condition. We’ve personally double-checked a few balance cards and found the work is pretty good—within a few grams at worst, versus our observations—but I’m in agreement with your machine shop. What if he takes the word of the “pre-balanced” package and it turns out to be way off? Then, who’s on the hook to make it right when it vibrates at cruising speed, or worse, self-destructs at 6,700 rpm?
Balancing a rotating/reciprocating assembly won’t add much to the total bill, so let them go ahead and double-check the crank-maker’s claims. Everybody will sleep better. As for the over/under-balance concept, let’s remember that balancing seeks to equalize the force generated by the rotating (round-and-round) and reciprocating (up-and-down) components. Since the connecting rods operate in both realms, things get complicated.
When working with a V-type engine with a 90-degree bank angle (all of our classic American V8s fall into this category), the process of balancing includes calculating the bob weight. Bob weights are temporarily attached masses equal to the total weight of two rotating masses and one reciprocating mass. Secured to the crank’s rod journals, they simulate the weight and motion of both the reciprocating and rotating masses as the crank is checked in the balancing machine, and it is here that some engine builders employ the over/under-balancing trick.
In a standard 90-degree V8, the reciprocating weight factor is calculated as being equal to 50 percent of the rotating weight (when assembling the bob weights). But if extremely high rpm levels are expected, inertial forces are naturally increased. Some crankshaft shops theorize that by increasing the reciprocating mass percentage to slightly more than the 50-percent norm—usually 51 or 52 percent—a more accurate bob weight total mass results. The resulting “over-balanced” crankshaft is thought to be better able to absorb the shock of extremely high piston velocity.
The wild card exposed by deviations from the normal bob-weight formula is an inevitable compromise in the quality of the balance (aka an unbalanced condition) at some other point in the rpm range. The only time overbalancing is called for is in extreme racing applications where crank speeds are going to remain at some well-known point, and operation at other rpm points are less important. In the real world of general-purpose street and strip fun machinery, this scenario is simply not encountered. Stick to the generally accepted balancing methods.
Can Cross-Drilled/Slotted Brake Rotors be Resurfaced?

Sam Haunterlover64; via CarCraft@carcraft.com: The left-rear shock-absorber mount on my 1972 El Camino SS broke off the axletube, and I was wondering where I can find a new bracket to weld on. Also, is it possible to surface cross-drilled disc-brake rotors?
Steve Magnante: I’m not aware of any outfits selling individual reproduction shock-absorber mounts to remedy your situation. I’m guessing rust ate away at your mount and there’s not enough left to repair and re-weld to the axletube. But it’s a fact companies like Currie, Drive Train Specialists, Moser, Quick Performance, Strange, and others sell ready-to-install axles that have all the required mounting ears, flanges, and mounts already attached for quick, bolt-in installation.
Knowing that, there’s a strong chance that a call to one of these outfits will result in the sale of the loose, individual mount you’re seeking. When you weld it to the axletube, make certain to match the original axle-to-shock orientation or you’ll introduce a bind that’ll kink the shock and cause trouble. If the axle is out of the car, don’t forget to emulate the original vehicle load and pinion angle when you weld the fresh bracket in place. If the axle is still under the bed of your El Camino, be sure to support the car under each axletube instead of by the frame with the rear suspension hanging down.
Regarding your question about resurfacing cross-drilled (and slotted) disc-brake rotors, the hassle involves the interrupted cut caused by the many drilled holes in the friction surfaces. Cutting tips can be quickly dulled and damaged by the rapid-fire load/unload shocks as the rotor spins in the lathe. The remedy is to take very light cuts of a few thousandths at a time and work up to the cutting depth needed to restore a smooth, flat friction surface. This adds time, especially if the drilled passages are offset on each face of the rotor (versus aligned holes made by a straight-through drilling operation). Offset holes require that one side of the rotor be cut at a time, where aligned holes allow for simultaneous cutting of both faces at once. Adding it all up, in some cases, the price of replacement rotors is less than the man-hours needed for refurbishment. Shop wisely. Also know that in high-volume shops (think Mercedes-Benz dealerships) where drilled rotors are encountered daily, specific resurfacing equipment is used. Instead of the single-point cutting tips used in most brake lathes, these establishments employ fluid-lubricated stones and turn the rotor at much higher speeds to restore freshness. The stones don’t get snagged in the holes like the pointed cutter and the fluid washes away grit that would otherwise flaw the surface finish.
These stone-type disc-brake rotor cutters are becoming more common as drilled and slotted disc-brake rotors grow in popularity. But remember, any time material is removed from a brake rotor, its ability to absorb and dissipate heat is compromised and it is forever less resistant to overheating under severe use. Be sure to check with the disc-brake manufacturer to learn how much material can safely be removed. Any disc with enough warping to be felt through the brake pedal (as a pulsation) has been severely overheated, is badly warped, and usually needs more material removal than is safe. Minor surface abrasions can safely be remedied, but more often than not, you’re best off simply replacing scarred rotors with fresh units.
NASCAR Valvetrain Tricks
David Borkowski; via CarCraft@carcraft.com: NASCAR runs pushrod V8 engines at 9,000 rpm. How do they make the valvetrain live for 500 miles?
Steve Magnante: You raise a good point. Unlike many other forms of endurance racing, which allow overhead-cam (OHC) engine architecture, NASCAR’s insistence on the use of pushrods and rocker arms places special challenges on the valvetrain. In an OHC engine, the relationship between the camshaft lobe and valve stem is direct, reducing the load on the valvesprings. Taking nothing away from Formula 1 or IndyCar engine builders, they don’t face the hassle of controlling the inertia of lifters, pushrods, and rocker arms like NASCAR engine builders do.
The magic behind how they get 358ci, pushrod-equipped V8s to deliver nearly 900 hp and live at 9,500 rpm for 500 miles comes down to metallurgy and harmonics. The wire used to make NASCAR valvesprings is carefully controlled for quality, then specially polished and coated with carbon and titanium nitride to eliminate the same kind of stress risers that can cause connecting rods to fail under load. Every part of the system is also made from the lightest—but strongest—metal available. Titanium valves with dainty stem diameters (as small as 6 mm) and valvespring retainers with scalloped edges and drilled perimeters shed many ounces. Special oil squirters target jets of engine oil against the springs to reduce inter-coil friction and carry away heat.
The engine blocks also play a role in valvetrain survival. The camshaft tunnels have been raised way up away from the spinning crank and enclosed in housings to keep flying oil from dragging on the crank. The raised cam also reduces the span between the lobes and rocker arms. This, in turn, allows for much shorter pushrods. And since the pushrods’ stiffness-to-mass ratio is dependent on overall length, these shorter pushrods reduce the load the valvesprings have to control. The added space inside the crankcase makes room for another group of oil squirters, targeting the pistons and rods.
Harmonics are another area of importance when crankshaft speed hits 9,500 rpm. The advent of modern testing equipment, like the Spin-Tron, exposed a raft of evils caused by high-frequency vibrations. In particular, the classic timing chain proved to be a major source of nasty harmonics leading to valvespring fatigue and failure. Though perfectly safe for daily use and occasional high-rpm spurts, constant operation at 9,000 rpm sets up shivers that run throughout the engine. By switching to a beltdriven cam (with NASCAR’s blessing), valvespring longevity was greatly improved due to the flexible belt’s ability to absorb the harsher notes played at 9K.
There are other tricks, but these are the major ingredients that allow today’s NASCAR engine builders to make the impossible possible. It’s a high-stakes race environment where cost is no object and a typical “bullet” costs $50,000.
Hot Coffin-Nose Cord
Solly Burton; Graysville, IN: I’m writing about my 85-year-old grandpa’s 1937 Cord 812. He bought it 25 years ago in Texas, but really got started rebuilding it eight years ago. He swapped a 1980 Oldsmobile Toronado 350 and FWD unit in the place of the original Lycoming flathead-eight and three-speed manual transaxle. It runs well, but we’ve been fighting an overheating problem for five years. So far we’ve had a bigger custom radiator made, tried numerous electric cooling fans, fan shrouds, coolant-expansion tanks, high-flow water pumps, coolant additives, and various thermostats—including running with no thermostat. Even after all this, it’ll get up to 210 degrees within 20 minutes of a dead-cold start-up. Last spring grandpa broke his hip, but he has already recovered—he’s pretty tough and a fast healer. He really wants to drive this car before he is too old.
Steve Magnante: Solly, give your grandpa a handshake for us for being persistent and not giving up. Before digging in, keep in mind that 212 degrees Fahrenheit isn’t a disastrous number. The happy zone for most gasoline-burning, internal-combustion engines is between 160 and 210 degrees. And in the case of many modern engines, 220 degrees is the norm to help curb exhaust emissions (but they’re designed for it with specific metallurgy, clearances, gaskets, and lubricant). Your 1980 Olds 350 really isn’t too far above the safety zone.
Having said that, you seem to have addressed all the obvious culprits that cause overheating, so it might be time to look at the engine itself. It isn’t unheard of for silt, rust, old gaskets, and other debris to accumulate inside an engine block and reduce the space/volume available for liquid coolant motion. Did you rebuild the Toronado engine or simply swap it over? Also, with the custom radiator you’ve undoubtedly got some non-stock hose routing. Are any hoses pinched or kinked from being installed within close quarters? A kinked hose will render even the best radiator on Earth null and void if coolant isn’t flowing to and from it freely, and don’t discount the fact that suction-side hoses can easily collapse if there is no coiled spring inside to add stiffness. This is a classic cause of engines that idle all day nice and cool but boil over at highway speed—when water-pump activity increases and sucks the return-side hose shut. Be sure the return-side hose is rigid and reinforced from within. Heck, why not replace any spans of straight hose more than 5 inches long with stainless-steel tubing of the correct diameter. That’ll rule out “collapsed veins.”
Beyond the hoses, look into your engine’s air/fuel mixture and ignition timing. An overly lean mixture under load can lead to overheating, as can retarded ignition timing. Make sure each item is within factory specs or is in the acceptable range for your application. Judging by the description, your grandpa’s Cord represents a sweet blend of stock and custom elements. The Cord 812 was only made in 1937 and was an outgrowth of the 1936 Cord 810. Company founder Errett Loban Cord only produced 2,830 810 and 812 Cords in 1936–1937, all of them right up the road from you in Auburn and Connersville, Indiana.
Hats off to grandpa for choosing a set of chromed 1966 Toronado rims. The wheels that came on the 1980 Toronado donor car were painted black, had different shapes, and were meant to be hidden under fake wire wheel covers (optional) or bland standard stainless hats. By contrast, the 1966 Toro rollers were deliberately designed by Oldsmobile to emulate the look of the original two-piece chromed wheel covers used by Cord. With their massive amount of inboard (negative) offset, they were designed to accommodate the extra width of the Toronado’s FWD system. Beyond that, GM research of the 1960s solved the vibration problem that haunted most previous FWD designs, regardless of origin. By placing the steering knuckle outside of the tire-tread centerline, rather than inside, and using double-jointed axleshafts, the resulting “outward pivot axis” forced wheel designers to go all the way with negative offset to keep the tires within the body shell.
When George Hurst and “Gentleman” Joe Schubeck created the Hurst Hairy Olds in 1966 (a 442 exhibition match racer with twin-Toronado powerplants driving both sets of tires), they retained the stock Toronado wheels! Yes, they looked great, but none of the aftermarket custom wheel makers—least of all Hurst—had an off-the-shelf mag that fit!
The post Car Craft Ask Anything: Answers to Your Burning Questions appeared first on Hot Rod Network.